Abdomen and chest examinations in peer physical examination: Variation in participation by gender

Katharine Reid; Ruth Sutherland; Agnes Dodds; Ruth McNair; David Pierce

doi:10.11157/fohpe.v16i2.66

Authors

Katharine Reid University of Melbourne
Ruth Sutherland
Agnes Dodds
Ruth McNair
David Pierce

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.11157/fohpe.v16i2.66

Keywords:

peer physical examination, medical students, clinical skills, student attitudes

Abstract

Aims:

To compare participation in peer physical examination (PPE) for male and female students when learning abdomen and chest examinations; to compare attitudes towards PPE for male and female students; and to determine if self-reported participation as examinees in PPE was related to attitudes towards PPE.

Background:

The opportunity to learn physical examination skills through practising with peers in formal tutorials is an important part of many medical curricula.

Method:

Students voluntarily completed a self-report questionnaire at the end of their third semester of medical training in which they rated their attitudes towards PPE and indicated how often they had been examined while practising abdomen and chest examinations.

Results:

Students volunteered to be examined less frequently in PPE when learning chest examination compared with abdominal examination; female students volunteered less frequently than male students for chest examinations but volunteered with similar frequency for abdomen examinations. Attitudes towards PPE were not related to student gender, but students who never volunteered for abdomen examinations tended to have higher average ratings for the perceived difficulty of PPE and lower ratings for the perceived value of PPE. Most students supplemented PPE with informal practice, although a majority practised exclusively with male volunteers.

Conclusions:

There is clear variation in participation rates for learning examinations for PPE of the abdomen and chest, but this variation is only partly explained by student gender and attitudes.

References

Barnette, J. J., Kreiter, C. D., & Schuldt, S. S. (2000). Student attitudes to same gender versus mixed gender partnering in practising physical examination skills. Evaluation and the Health Professions, 23, 361–372.

Bhoopatkar, H., & Wearn, A. (2008). Medical students describe their patterns of practising clinical examination skills outside timetabled sessions. Medical Teacher 30(3), 334.

Braunack-Mayer, A. J. (2001). Should medical students act as surrogate patients for each other? Medical Education, 35, 681–686.

Chang, E. H., & Power, D. V. (2000). Are medical students comfortable with practising physical examinations on each other? Academic Medicine, 75, 384–389.

Chen, J. Y., Yip, A. L. M., Lam, C. L. K., & Patil, N. G. (2011). Does medical student willingness to practice peer physical examination translate into action? Medical Teacher, 33, 528–540.

Fagan, M. J., Lucero, M. L., Wu, E. H., Diaz, J. A., & Reinert, S. E. (2006). Attitudes toward the physical examination: A comparison of US and Dominican medical students. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 18, 287–291.

McLachlan, J. C., White, P., Donnelly, L., & Patten, D. (2010). Student attitudes to peer physical examination: A qualitative study of changes in expressed willingness to participate. Medical Teacher, 32, 101–105.

O'Neill, P. A., Larcombe, C., Duffy, K., & Dorman, T. L. (1998). Medical students' willingness and reactions to learning basic skills through examining fellow students. Medical Teacher, 20, 433–437.

Outram, S., & Nair, B. R. (2008). Peer physical examination: Time to revisit. Medical Journal of Australia, 189, 274–276.

Power, D. V., & Center, B. A. (2005). Examining the medical student body: Peer physical exams and genital, rectal, or breast exams. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 14, 337–343.

Rees, C. (2007). The influence of gender on student willingness to engage in peer physical examination: The practical implications of feminist theory of body image. Medical Education, 41, 801–807.

Rees, C., Bradley, P., Collett, T., & McLachlan, J. (2005). Over my dead body? The influence of demographics on students' willingness to participate in peer physical examination. Medical Teacher, 27, 599–605.

Rees, C., Bradley, P., & McLachlan, J. (2004). Exploring medical students' attitudes towards peer physical examination. Medical Teacher, 26, 86–88.

Rees, C., Wearn, A., Vnuk, A., & Bradley, P. (2009). Don’t want to show fellow students my naughty bits: Medical students’ anxieties about peer examination of intimate body regions at six schools across UK, Australasia and Far-East Asia. Medical Teacher, 31, 921–927.

Rees, C., Wearn, A., Vnuk, A., & Sato, T. (2009). Medical students' attitudes towards peer physical examination: Findings from an international cross-sectional and longitudinal study. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 14, 103–121.

Reid, K. J., Kgakololo, M., Sutherland, R. M., Elliott, S. L., & Dodds, A. E. (2012). First-year medical students' willingness to participate in peer physical examination. Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 24, 55–62.

Wearn, A., Rees, C., Bhoopatkar, H., Bradley, P., Lam, C., McLachlan, J., . . . Vnuk, A. (2008). What not to touch: Medical students from six schools report on peer physical examination in clinical skills and anatomy learning. Focus on Health Professional Education: A Multi-disciplinary Journal, 10(2), 24.

Wearn, A., Rees, C., Bradley, P., & Vnuk, A. (2008). Understanding student concerns about peer physical examination using an activity theory framework. Medical Education, 42, 1218–1226.