The quantitative impact of placements on allied health time use and productivity in healthcare facilities: a systematic review with meta-analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11157/fohpe.v20i2.315Keywords:
allied health, clinical education, meta-analysis, productivity, student placement, systematic review, time useAbstract
Introduction: The current and future health needs of the population pose challenges for healthcare services, which face increased pressure for service provision, and for universities educating graduates to meet this clinical demand. One aspect influencing allied health (AH) clinician willingness to offer student placements is the perceptions of impact on patient activity levels and clinician time. This systematic review synthesises the evidence quantifying student impact on AH patient activity, clinician time and productivity.
Methods: Searches of peer-reviewed literature published since 1990 were conducted in Medline, CINAHL, Scopus and EMBASE and supplemented by other sources. Selected studies reported clinician-recorded patient activity and/or time participating in services provided by nutrition and dietetics, occupational therapy, physiotherapy and speech pathology, with and without students present. Studies meeting eligibility criteria (n = 23) were rated using the McMaster Guidelines for Critical Review Form: Quantitative Studies. Effect size calculations and meta-analysis were planned if sufficient studies reported similar outcome measures.
Results: Seventeen studies contributed to four meta-analyses: patient activity levels, direct clinical time, clinical billed units and direct time per patient. Pooled results were neutral or favoured increases in activity or time during student placements. Methodological variation and research quality inhibited more comprehensive analysis.
Conclusions: Data showed students may have a neutral or positive effect on AH patient activity levels and clinical time. Potential factors influencing data are discussed, and the areas of focus for further research are suggested.
References
Abey, S., Lea, S., Callaghan, L., Shaw, S., & Cotton, D. (2015). Identifying
factors which enhance capacity to engage in clinical education among podiatry
practitioners: An action research project. Journal of Foot and Ankle Research, 8, 66.
doi:10.1186/s13047-015-0123-4
Ash, S., Martin, E. K., Rodger, S., Clark, M., & Graves, N. (2015). Student and
supervisor productivity change during nutrition and dietetic practice placements:
A cohort study. Nutrition & Dietetics, 72 (2), 163–169. doi:10.1111/1747-
12093
Borenstein, M., Hegdes, L. V., Higgins, J. P. T., & Rothstein, H. R. (2009).
Introduction to meta-analysis. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
Borenstein, M., Hedges, L., Higgins, J. P. T., & Rothstein, H. R. (2014).
Comprehensive Meta Analysis Version 3.0. Englewood, NJ: BioStat.
Borenstein, M., Higgins, J. P. T., Hedges, L. V., & Rothstein, H. R. (2017). Basics
of meta-analysis: I2 is not an absolute measure of heterogeneity. Research Synthesis
Methods, 8(1), 5–18. doi:10.1002/jrsm.1230
Bowles, K., Haines, T. P., Molloy, E., Kent, F., Sevenhuysen, S., & Tai, J. (2014). The
costs and benefits of providing undergraduate student clinical placements for a health
service organisation: A rapid review. Retrieved from https://www.saxinstitute.org.au/
wp-content/uploads/The-costs-and-benefits-of-providing-undergraduate-studentclinical-
place....pdf
Briffa, C., & Porter, J. (2013). A systematic review of the collaborative clinical
education model to inform speech-language pathology practice. International
Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 15(6), 564–574. doi:10.3109/17549507.20
763290
Bristow, D., & Hagler, P. (1994). Impact of physical therapy students on patient
service delivery and professional staff time. Physiotherapy Canada, 46(4), 275–280.
Bristow, D., & Hagler, P. (1997). Comparison of individual physical therapists'
productivity to that of combined physical therapist–student pairs. Physiotherapy
Canada, 49(1), 16–23.
Campbell, N., Eley, D. S., & McAllister, L. (2014). Investigating personality and
conceptualising allied health as person or technique oriented. Australian Health
Review, 38(1), 86–92. doi:10.1071/ah13109
Casares, G. S., Bradley, K. P., Jaffe, L. E., & Lee, G. P. (2003). Impact of the changing
health care environment on fieldwork education: Perceptions of occupational
therapy educators. Journal of Allied Health, 32(4), 246–251.
Coulson, E., Woekel, D., Copenhauer, R., Gallatin, T., Hawkins, J., Hixson, L.,
& Pruim, C. (1991). Effects of clinical education on the productivity of private
practice facilities. Journal of Physical Therapy Education, 5(1), 29–32.
Davies, R., Hanna, E., & Cott, C. (2011). “They put you on your toes”: Physical
therapists' perceived benefits from and barriers to supervising students in the
clinical setting. Physiotherapy Canada, 63(2), 224–233.
Dean, C. M., Alam, M., & Refshauge, K. (2010). Clinical training requirements for
the Faculty of Health Sciences. Synergy, 30, 22–27.
Dillon, L. S., Tomaka, J. W., Chriss, C. E., Gutierrez, C. P., & Hairston, J. M.
(2003). The effect of student clinical experiences on clinician productivity. Journal
of Allied Health, 32(4), 261–265.
Dupont, L., Gauthier-Gagnon, C., Roy, R., & Lamoureux, M. (1997). Group
supervision and productivity: From myth to reality. Journal of Physical Therapy
Education, 11(2), 31–37.
Evenson, M. E., Roberts, M., Kaldenberg, J., Barnes, M. A., & Ozelie, R. (2015).
National Survey of Fieldwork Educators: Implications for occupational therapy
education. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 69(Suppl. 2), 1–5.
doi:10.5014/ajot.2015.019265
Graham, C. L., Catlin, P., Morgan, J., & Martin, E. (1991). Comparison of 1-dayper-
week, 1-week, and 5-week clinical education experiences. Journal of Physical
Therapy Education, 5(1), 18–23.
Hall, M., Poth, C., Manns, P., & Beaupre, L. (2015). To supervise or not to supervise
a physical therapist student: A national survey of Canadian physical therapists.
Journal of Physical Therapy Education, 29(3), 58–67.
Hancock, J. J. (1997). Impact of speech-language pathology students on patient care.
Unpublished master’s thesis, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Hancock, J., & Hagler, P. (1998). A pilot study of the effects of SL-P practicum
students on service delivery. Journal of Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology,
(3), 141–150.
Health Workforce Australia (HWA). (2014). Australia’s health workforce series:
Speech pathologists in focus. Retrieved from https://industry.gov.au/Office-of-the-
Chief-Economist/SkilledOccupationList/Documents/2015Submissions/Speech-
Pathology-Australia.pdf
Holland, K. A. (1997). Does taking students increase your waiting lists? Physiotherapy,
(4), 166–172.
Huddleston, R. (1999). Clinical placements for the professions allied to medicine,
part 2: Placement shortages? Two models that can solve the problem. The British
Journal of Occupational Therapy, 62(7), 295–298.
Ilott, I. (1996). Ranking the problems of fieldwork supervision reveals a new problem:
Failing students. The British Journal of Occupational Therapy, 59(11), 525–528.
doi:10.1177/030802269605901110
Ladyshewsky, R. K. (1995). Enhancing service productivity in acute care inpatient
settings using a collaborative clinical education model. Physical Therapy, 75(6),
–510.
Ladyshewsky, R. K., Barrie, S. C., & Drake, V. M. (1998). A comparison of
productivity and learning outcome in individual and cooperative physical therapy
clinical education models. Physical Therapy, 78(12), 1288–1298.
Ladyshewsky, R., Bird, N., & Finney, J. (1994). The impact on departmental
productivity during physical therapy student placements: An investigation of
outpatient physical therapy services. Physiotherapy Canada, 46(2), 89–93.
Law, M., Stewart, D., Pollock, N., Letts, L., Bosch, J., & Westmorland, M. (2014).
Guidelines for critical review form: Quantitative studies. Retrieved from https://srsmcmaster.
ca/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Guidelines-for-Critical-Review-Form-
Quantiative-Studies-English.pdf
Law, M., Stewart, D., Pollock, N., Letts, L., Bosch, J., Westmorland, M., & Philpot,
A. (1998). Evidence-based practice research group. Retrieved from https://srsmcmaster.
ca/research/evidence-based-practice-research-group/
Lekkas, P., Larsen, T., Kumar, S., Grimmer, K., Nyland, L., Chipchase, L., . . . Finch,
J. (2007). No model of clinical education for physiotherapy students is superior to
another: A systematic review. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy, 53(1), 19–28.
Liberati, A., Altman, D. G., Tetzlaff, J., Mulrow, C., Gøtzsche, P. C., Ioannidis, J.
P. A., . . . Moher, D. (2009). The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic
reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions:
Explanation and elaboration. PLOS Medicine, 6(7), e1000100. doi:10.1371/
journal.pmed.1000100
Lindeblad, S. K. (1998). Comparison of two clinical education models on the functioning
of three acute care physical therapy departments. Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida.
Loewen, P., Legal, M., Gamble, A., Shah, K., Tkachuk, S., & Zed, P. (2017). Learner:
preceptor ratios for practice‐based learning across health disciplines: A systematic
review. Medical Education, 51(2), 146–157. doi:10.1111/medu.13144
MacDonald, C. A., Cox, P. D., & Bartlett, D. J. (2002). Productivity and client
satisfaction: A comparison between physical therapists and student–therapist pairs.
Physiotherapy Canada, 54(2), 92–101.
McAllister, L. (2005). Issues and innovations in clinical education.
International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 7(3), 138–148.
doi:10.1080/14417040500181239
Moher, D., Liberati, A., Tetzlaff, J., Altman, D. G., & The, P. G. (2009). Preferred
reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement.
PLOS Medicine, 6(7), e1000097. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097
Moore, J. H., Glenesk, K. T., Hulsizer, D. K., McCright, B. E., Wrenn, C., & Sander,
T., . . . Childs, J. D. (2014). Impact of an innovative clinical internship model in
the US Army-Baylor Doctoral Program in physical therapy. The United States Army
Medical Department Journal, Jan–Mar, 30–34.
National Health Workforce Taskforce. (2009). Health workforce in Australia
and factors for current shortages. Retrieved from http://webarchive.nla.gov.au/
gov/20160226234255/http://www.ahwo.gov.au/documents/NHWT/The%20
health%20workforce%20in%20Australia%20and%20factors%20influencing%20
current%20shortages.pdf
O'Brien, C. W., Anderson, R., Ayzenberg, B., Chute, P., Farnsworth, T., McLaughlin,
R., . . . Maillet, J. O. S. (2017). Employers’ viewpoint on clinical education.
Journal of Allied Health, 46(3), 131–137.
Ozelie, R., Janow, J., Kreutz, C., Mulry, M. K., & Penkala, A. (2015). Supervision
of occupational therapy level II fieldwork students: Impact on and predictors
of clinician productivity. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 69(1), 1–7.
doi:10.5014/ajot.2015.013532
Pabian, P. S., Dyson, J., & Levine, C. (2017). Physical therapist productivity using a
collaborative clinical education model within an acute care setting: A longitudinal
study. Journal of Physical Therapy Education, 31(2), 11–17.
Paterson, M. L. (1997). Clinician productivity with and without students. The
Occupational Therapy Journal of Research, 17(1), 48–54.
Phelan, S. E., Daniels, M. G., & Hewitt, L. (1999). The costs and benefits of clinical
education. Laboratory Medicine, 30(11), 714–720.
Pivko, S. E., Abbruzzese, L. D., Duttaroy, P., Hansen, R. L., & Ryans, K. (2016).
Effect of physical therapy students' clinical experiences on clinician productivity.
Journal of Allied Health, 45(1), 33–40.
Pretorius, A., Karunaratne, N., & Fehring, S. (2016). Australian physiotherapy
workforce at a glance: A narrative review. Australian Health Review, 40(4), 438–
doi:10.1071/AH15114
Rindflesch, A. B., Dunfee, H. J., Cieslak, K. R., Eischen, S. L., Trenary, T., Calley, D.
Q., & Heinle, D. K. (2009). Collaborative model of clinical education in physical
and occupational therapy at the Mayo Clinic. Journal of Allied Health, 38(3),
–142.
Roberts, M., Evenson, M. E., Kaldenberg, J., Barnes, M. A., & Ozelie, R. (2015, May
. Fieldwork education survey: Demand for innovative and creative solutions.
OT Practice, 15–16. Retrieved from https://www.aota.org/Publications-News/otp/
Archive/2015.aspx
Rodger, S., Stephens, E., Clark, M., Ash, S., & Graves, N. (2011). Occupational
therapy students' contribution to occasions of service during practice placements
in health settings. Australian Occupational Therapy Journal, 58(6), 412–418.
Rodger, S., Stephens, E., Clark, M., Ash, S., Hurst, C., & Graves, N. (2012).
Productivity and time use during occupational therapy and nutrition/dietetics
clinical education: A cohort study. PLoS ONE, 7(8), e44356. doi:10.1371/journal.
pone.0044356
Rodger, S., Webb, G., Devitt, L., Gilbert, J., Wrightson, J., & McMeeken, J. (2008).
Clinical education and practice placements in the allied health professions: An
international perspective. Journal of Allied Health, 37(1), 53–62.
Schlosser, R. W., Wendt, O., & Sigafoos, J. (2007). Not all systematic reviews are
created equal: Considerations for appraisal. Evidence-Based Communication
Assessment and Intervention, 1(3), 138–150. doi:10.1080/17489530701560831
Sevenhuysen, S. L., & Haines, T. (2011). The slave of duty: Why clinical educators
across the continuum of care provide clinical education in physiotherapy. Hong
Kong Physiotherapy Journal, 29(2), 64–70.
Short, K., Lincoln, M., & Gilsenan, K. (2001). The evaluation of the impact of
student placements on a large area health service. Paper presented at the National
Conference of the Speech Pathology Association of Australia, Melbourne, Victoria,
Australia.
Sterne, J. A. C., Sutton, A. J., Ioannidis, J. P. A., Terrin, N., Jones, D. R., Lau, J., . . .
Higgins, J. P. T. (2011). Recommendations for examining and interpreting funnel
plot asymmetry in meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials. BMJ, 343(7818),
–307. doi:10.1136/bmj.d4002
United States Department of Labor (2018). Occupational outlook handbook. Retrieved
Valentine, J. C., Pigott, T. D., & Rothstein, H. R. (2010). How many studies do you
need? A Primer on statistical power for meta-analysis. Journal of Educational and
Behavioral, 35(3), 375.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
On acceptance for publication in FoHPE the copyright of the manuscript is signed over to ANZAHPE, the publisher of FoHPE.
